Header Notice

Winter is here! Check out the winter wonderlands at these 5 amazing winter destinations in Montana

It’s Time To Break Up With Airbnb


Modified: December 28, 2023

by Wandie Stromberg



Over the past decade, Airbnb has revolutionized the way people travel, offering unique accommodations in local neighborhoods and allowing travelers to experience a destination like a local. With its user-friendly platform and competitive pricing, it quickly became a popular choice for travelers looking for alternatives to traditional hotels. However, as the platform has grown in popularity, so have the concerns and problems associated with it.


In this article, we will delve into the rise of Airbnb, examine the problems that have emerged as a result, and explore the impact of this platform on local communities. We will also discuss the lack of regulation and oversight, the issues of exploitation and unfair competition, as well as safety and security concerns. Finally, we will highlight some alternative options to Airbnb that offer a more ethical and sustainable approach to accommodations.


While Airbnb has undoubtedly disrupted the hospitality industry, it is important to critically examine its effects on cities, communities, and the overall travel experience. By taking a closer look at the challenges it presents, we can better understand the need for alternative solutions that strike a balance between the sharing economy and the well-being of local residents and tourists alike.


The Rise of Airbnb

Founded in 2008, Airbnb quickly rose to prominence as a disruptive force in the travel industry. The platform offered a unique proposition – the ability to rent out spare rooms, apartments, or even entire houses to travelers, essentially turning everyday people into hosts. This concept captured the imagination of travelers seeking more authentic and personalized experiences away from the traditional hotel scene.


Airbnb gained traction by tapping into the sharing economy trend, allowing both hosts and guests to benefit. Hosts could monetize their underutilized spaces, while guests could enjoy more affordable accommodations and immerse themselves in the local culture. The company’s user-friendly interface, extensive listing options, and secure payment system contributed to its rapid growth.


The appeal of Airbnb extended beyond financial benefits. Travelers sought the opportunity to live like locals, exploring hidden neighborhoods, and discovering unique cultural experiences. The platform facilitated a sense of community, with hosts often providing valuable insights and recommendations to enhance the guests’ stay. This sense of connection and personal touch set Airbnb apart from traditional hotels, cementing its popularity.


In addition, Airbnb benefited from the rise of social media and positive word-of-mouth. Guests who had enjoyable experiences would share their stories, photos, and recommendations with friends and followers, further boosting Airbnb’s reputation and attracting new users.


Embracing the concept of “home away from home,” Airbnb capitalized on the desire for more authentic and memorable travel experiences. By providing a vast array of unique and diverse accommodations, from cozy apartments to remote cabins, the platform became a go-to choice for travelers seeking a break from the cookie-cutter hotel experience.


As a result of its rapid growth and global reach, Airbnb has become a major player in the travel industry, significantly impacting the way people book accommodations and reshaping the hospitality landscape.


Problems with Airbnb

While Airbnb has undoubtedly brought forth many benefits and opportunities, it has also faced a fair share of criticisms and challenges. Here are some of the key problems associated with the platform:

  1. Overtourism: One of the major issues with Airbnb is its contribution to overtourism in popular destinations. With the growth of short-term rentals, neighborhoods that were once residential are now overrun with tourists, causing disruption to the daily lives of locals, straining local infrastructure, and driving up the cost of living.
  2. Housing Affordability: The increasing popularity of Airbnb has led to a shortage of long-term rental housing. Many property owners have opted to list their properties on Airbnb, reducing the availability of affordable housing options for residents. This has exacerbated the housing crisis in cities, particularly in high-demand areas.
  3. Loss of Community: The rise of Airbnb has also led to a decline in community cohesion. With many properties being used as short-term rentals, neighborhoods become transient, and long-term residents may feel disconnected from their neighbors. This can result in the loss of a sense of community and a decrease in social interactions.
  4. Unfair Competition: Traditional hoteliers argue that Airbnb hosts should be subject to the same regulations and taxes as hotels. This creates an unfair playing field, as hotels have to comply with strict regulations and licensing procedures, while Airbnb hosts often operate without such oversight.
  5. Safety and Security: Another concern is the lack of consistent safety standards on the platform. While Airbnb has implemented safety measures, including host verifications and guest reviews, incidents of theft, vandalism, and unauthorized surveillance have been reported. The lack of a standardized safety protocol can leave both guests and hosts vulnerable.

These problems highlight the need for greater regulation, accountability, and responsible management of short-term rental platforms like Airbnb. Striking a balance between the benefits of the sharing economy and the well-being of local communities is crucial in addressing these concerns and ensuring sustainable tourism practices.


Impact on Local Communities

The influx of short-term rentals through platforms like Airbnb has had significant impacts on local communities, both positive and negative. Here are some key ways in which Airbnb has shaped and affected local communities:

  1. Economic Benefits: Airbnb can provide an economic boost to communities by allowing local residents to earn supplemental income through hosting. This extra money can have a positive effect on revenue and local businesses, as guests often spend money on dining, shopping, and attractions in the neighborhood.
  2. Displacement of Residents: The rise of Airbnb has resulted in the displacement of long-term residents in some areas. As property owners convert their homes into short-term rentals, it reduces the available housing for local residents, particularly in highly desirable neighborhoods. This can lead to higher rent prices and housing shortages, making it difficult for locals to find affordable housing.
  3. Social Impacts: The presence of short-term rentals can impact the social fabric of a neighborhood. With a constant stream of transient guests, it can be challenging for residents to establish a sense of community and develop meaningful relationships with their neighbors. The revolving door of guests may lead to a lack of accountability and shared responsibility within the community.
  4. Cultural Authenticity: Some argue that the rise of Airbnb can dilute the authenticity of a destination’s culture. As travelers opt for Airbnb accommodations over locally-owned hotels, they may miss out on the unique cultural experiences and interactions that come with staying in traditional accommodations. This can contribute to a homogenization of the tourism experience.
  5. Tourism Management: The rapid growth of Airbnb has posed challenges for local governments in managing tourism. Local regulations and policies may not be equipped to handle the increasing number of short-term rentals, resulting in a lack of oversight and enforcement. This can lead to conflicts between hosts, residents, and local authorities.

It is crucial for local communities to strike a balance between the economic benefits of tourism and the preservation of their social fabric, affordable housing, and cultural heritage. Implementing effective regulations and responsible tourism practices can help mitigate the negative impacts and ensure a sustainable future for both residents and visitors.


Lack of Regulation and Oversight

One of the major issues surrounding Airbnb is the lack of regulation and oversight in many jurisdictions. As the platform grew in popularity, it outpaced local regulatory frameworks, leaving a vacuum in terms of laws and enforcement. Here are some key aspects of the lack of regulation and oversight:

  1. Regulatory Frameworks: Traditional hotels and accommodation providers are subject to various regulations to ensure safety, quality, and compliance. However, short-term rentals like Airbnb often operate in a legal gray area, with inconsistent regulations or a lack of clear guidelines. This can create a sense of unfairness and confusion among hosts, guests, and local authorities.
  2. Taxation: Another concern is the taxation of Airbnb rentals. Hotels and other lodging businesses are required to collect and remit various taxes, such as occupancy taxes and tourism taxes, which contribute to the local economy. Airbnb has faced criticism for not consistently collecting and remitting these taxes, potentially resulting in lost revenue for local governments.
  3. Residential Zoning Laws: Many cities have zoning regulations that define specific areas for residential or commercial use. In some cases, Airbnb hosts may be operating in violation of these zoning laws, as residential properties are converted into de facto hotel accommodations. This raises concerns regarding the preservation of residential neighborhoods and the disruption of community dynamics.
  4. Enforcement Challenges: The lack of effective enforcement mechanisms further exacerbates the regulatory issues. Local authorities may struggle to identify and address illegal or non-compliant rentals, especially in high-demand areas. This not only undermines fair competition but also hampers efforts to maintain the integrity and character of neighborhoods.
  5. Accountability: Without robust regulations, there can be a lack of accountability for hosts and guests on the platform. While Airbnb has introduced measures to verify hosts and collect guest reviews, it can still be challenging to address issues such as noise disturbances, property damage, or breaches of community guidelines effectively.

The lack of regulation and oversight regarding short-term rentals has led to calls for greater transparency, accountability, and collaboration between platforms like Airbnb and local authorities. Striking a balance that protects the interests of all stakeholders – hosts, guests, residents, and local governments – is necessary to ensure a fair and sustainable accommodation ecosystem.


Exploitation and Unfair Competition

As the popularity of Airbnb continues to grow, concerns have emerged about exploitation and unfair competition within the accommodation industry. Here are some key aspects of this problem:

  1. Professionalized Hosts: While Airbnb was initially intended to allow individuals to rent out their spare rooms or properties, some hosts have turned it into a full-time business. These professionalized hosts, who may own multiple properties solely for short-term rental purposes, have an advantage over individuals seeking long-term rentals, as they can offer competitive rates due to economies of scale. This has led to a higher concentration of rental units in the hands of a few, limiting options for residents and contributing to housing affordability issues.
  2. Commercial Operators: In some cases, commercial operators have taken advantage of the sharing economy model by purchasing properties solely for use as short-term rentals. These operators can offer numerous listings, often outpricing traditional hotels in terms of both cost and variety. This can create an uneven playing field, as hotels are subject to stricter regulations and costs.
  3. Unfair Pricing and Availability: The surge in short-term rentals has led to increased demand and subsequent price inflation in some markets. This can make it challenging for locals, particularly lower-income residents, to find affordable housing options. Additionally, the availability of long-term rental units may dwindle as property owners opt for the higher returns associated with short-term rentals.
  4. Negative Impact on Local Businesses: The proliferation of Airbnb rentals can also have a negative impact on local businesses. With visitors opting for Airbnb accommodations instead of traditional hotels, local restaurants, cafes, and other establishments may experience a decline in customers. This can lead to a loss of revenue and potential closures, disproportionately affecting small, locally-owned businesses.
  5. Disruption to Neighborhood Character: The high turnover and transient nature of Airbnb guests can disrupt the character of residential neighborhoods. The constant influx of visitors may lead to noise disturbances, increased traffic, and a transient atmosphere, disturbing the peace and tranquility of a community.

Solutions to address these issues include implementing stricter regulations and licensing requirements for short-term rentals, putting limits on the number of properties an individual can operate, and enforcing fair competition among hosts. By promoting a level playing field and ensuring that the interests of both residents and businesses are safeguarded, a more sustainable and equitable accommodation landscape can be achieved.


Safety and Security Concerns

While Airbnb has implemented safety measures and guidelines, there are still valid concerns regarding the safety and security of both hosts and guests. Here are some key aspects to consider:

  1. Verification Process: While hosts on Airbnb are encouraged to undergo a verification process, there is no guarantee that all hosts have undergone the same level of screening. This lack of consistency raises concerns about the reliability of host profiles and the potential for fraudulent activity.
  2. Unauthorized Surveillance: Reports of hidden cameras and unauthorized surveillance in some Airbnb rentals have raised significant privacy concerns. Guests have discovered hidden cameras or other recording devices, breaching their privacy and raising questions about the security measures in place.
  3. Property Safety: As Airbnb listings vary in terms of quality and maintenance, guests may encounter safety issues within the rental properties. This could range from hazards such as faulty wiring, inadequate fire safety measures, or other potential risks that could compromise the well-being of guests.
  4. Disputes and Conflict Resolution: In the event of conflicts or disputes between hosts and guests, the resolution process can be challenging. Airbnb’s customer service teams play a crucial role in mediating disputes, but the effectiveness and speed of resolution may vary, leaving both parties feeling frustrated and dissatisfied.
  5. Community Safety: The use of residential properties as short-term rentals can also impact the safety of the surrounding community. A constant influx of unfamiliar guests may raise concerns about the overall security of the neighborhood and can strain local law enforcement resources.

Airbnb has recognized these concerns and taken steps to address them by implementing trust and safety measures such as host verifications, guest reviews, and refund policies. However, it is important for both hosts and guests to exercise caution and research their options before making or accepting bookings.


To address these safety concerns more comprehensively, regulatory authorities can play a role in establishing and enforcing safety standards for short-term rentals. This can include requiring hosts to adhere to specific safety protocols, conducting regular inspections, and implementing mechanisms for reporting and resolving safety issues.


Ultimately, the responsibility for ensuring safety and security falls on both the platform and the individuals involved. By promoting transparency, accountability, and clear guidelines, the safety concerns associated with Airbnb can be mitigated, creating a more secure and trustworthy experience for all parties involved.


Alternatives to Airbnb

As the issues surrounding Airbnb become more apparent, travelers and hosts alike are seeking alternative platforms and accommodations that offer a more ethical and sustainable approach. Here are some alternatives to consider:

  1. Local Boutique Hotels: Instead of opting for large chain hotels, consider supporting local boutique hotels that offer unique and authentic experiences. These hotels often have a strong connection to the community, provide personalized service, and showcase local culture and design.
  2. Homestay Networks: Homestay networks connect travelers with local hosts who are willing to share their homes and experiences. These platforms prioritize cultural exchange and provide an opportunity to immerse oneself in the local community.
  3. Hostels and Guesthouses: Hostels and guesthouses are budget-friendly options that promote social interactions among travelers. They cater to a wide range of travelers, from solo adventurers to groups, and often offer communal spaces and organized activities.
  4. Glamping: For nature lovers, glamping (glamorous camping) offers a unique accommodation experience. It combines the comforts of a hotel with the immersive experience of camping, allowing travelers to connect with nature while enjoying luxurious amenities.
  5. Vacation Rentals Managed by Local Agencies: Instead of booking through a large online platform, consider seeking out local agencies that manage vacation rentals. These agencies often have a closer relationship with the property owners, ensuring more consistent quality and responsiveness.
  6. Eco-Lodges and Sustainable Retreats: For travelers looking for eco-friendly and sustainable options, eco-lodges and sustainable retreats provide accommodations that are designed to have minimal impact on the environment. These properties often incorporate sustainable practices and offer educational experiences centered around environmental conservation.

When considering alternatives to Airbnb, it is important to conduct thorough research, read reviews, and ensure that the chosen accommodations align with personal values and preferences. Supporting local businesses and engaging in responsible tourism practices can contribute to the well-being of local communities and the preservation of cultural heritage.


By exploring these alternatives, travelers can have a more diverse and enriching travel experience while supporting a more sustainable and responsible approach to accommodation.



Airbnb has undoubtedly revolutionized the way we travel, offering unique and immersive accommodation experiences. However, it is important to critically examine the problems associated with the platform and consider the impacts it has on local communities, housing affordability, fair competition, and safety.


The lack of regulation and oversight surrounding Airbnb has given rise to issues such as overtourism, housing shortages, and concerns about safety and security. Additionally, the platform has faced criticism for enabling unfair competition and undermining the character of residential neighborhoods.


Nevertheless, there are alternatives to Airbnb that offer a more ethical and sustainable approach. Exploring options such as local boutique hotels, homestays, guesthouses, and eco-lodges can provide travelers with unique experiences while supporting the local economy and fostering a sense of community.


To address the challenges posed by short-term rental platforms like Airbnb, it is vital for local authorities to implement effective regulations and enforcement mechanisms. Clear guidelines and legal frameworks can ensure fairness, transparency, and safety for both hosts and guests.


Furthermore, travelers have a role to play in responsible tourism. By practicing conscious booking, supporting local businesses, being respectful of the community, and adhering to guidelines, travelers can contribute positively to the destinations they visit.


In conclusion, while Airbnb has brought about significant changes to the travel industry, it is crucial to recognize and address the problems it has created. By striving for a balance between the benefits of the sharing economy and the well-being of local communities, we can ensure a more sustainable and responsible approach to accommodations, benefiting both residents and travelers alike.