Header Notice

Winter is here! Check out the winter wonderlands at these 5 amazing winter destinations in Montana

Black Tap And The Craziest Milkshakes In New York City


Modified: December 27, 2023

by Abigale Cheeks



When it comes to food travel, there are few experiences as enticing as indulging in delicious treats from around the world. And if you’re a fan of both food and travel, then you’re in for a real treat in New York City. The Big Apple is home to a vast array of culinary delights, with each neighborhood offering its own unique culinary experiences. From street food vendors serving up delectable snacks to high-end restaurants with renowned chefs, the options are endless.


Among the many culinary hotspots in New York City, one name stands out for its innovative take on a classic American treat – Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer. Known for their over-the-top milkshakes that are as Instagrammable as they are delicious, Black Tap has become a must-visit destination for food lovers and travel enthusiasts.


The rise of Black Tap has been nothing short of extraordinary. What started as a humble burger joint in the heart of Manhattan quickly gained popularity thanks to their extraordinary milkshakes. These milkshakes, unlike anything you’ve ever seen before, are a delightful blend of creativity, flavor, and audacity.


The art of milkshake making has been taken to a whole new level at Black Tap. Their skilled team of mixologists and pastry chefs work tirelessly to create milkshakes that not only taste incredible but also look like edible works of art. With their colorful toppings, towering whipped cream, and unique presentation, the milkshakes at Black Tap are a visual feast for the eyes.


Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or prefer to venture into the realm of the unconventional, Black Tap has a milkshake for everyone. From the traditional vanilla and chocolate shakes to the unique and outrageous creations, there’s no shortage of options to satisfy your sweet tooth.


In this article, we will take a closer look at the classic milkshakes offered at Black Tap, as well as the craziest milkshakes on their menu. We’ll delve into the indulgent world of Black Tap’s specialty shakes and explore their seasonal offerings. So buckle up and get ready to embark on a mouthwatering journey through the world of Black Tap’s milkshakes.


The Rise of Black Tap

Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer may have started as a small burger joint in New York City, but it quickly gained a reputation for its exceptional milkshakes. What began as a local hotspot soon became a global sensation, attracting queues of eager foodies from all over the world.


The story of Black Tap’s rise to prominence is a testament to the power of social media. It all started in 2015 when the creative milkshake creations began appearing on various Instagram feeds. The vibrant colors, towering whipped cream, and unique toppings caught the attention of food bloggers and influencers, sparking a viral sensation.


As the demand for their milkshakes skyrocketed, Black Tap quickly expanded from its original location in Manhattan’s SoHo neighborhood to multiple locations across New York City. Today, they have even opened branches in Las Vegas, Los Angeles, and internationally in Dubai and Singapore.


One of the key factors behind Black Tap’s success is its ability to create a unique experience for its customers. Walking into one of their restaurants feels like stepping into a 1950s soda shop, with its vintage decor and classic diner ambiance. The energetic and friendly staff only heighten the overall experience, making each visit feel like a celebration of food and fun.


Another reason for Black Tap’s rise in popularity is its commitment to quality. The milkshakes are made with premium ingredients, including homemade ice cream, and are crafted with meticulous attention to detail. Each shake is prepared by highly skilled mixologists who expertly blend flavors and construct captivating presentations.


Black Tap’s success has also been fueled by its ability to keep innovating. They regularly introduce new flavors and inventive toppings to their menu, constantly pushing the boundaries of what a milkshake can be. This dedication to creativity and constant reinvention has kept customers coming back for more.


Undoubtedly, the power of social media has played a crucial role in Black Tap’s ascension. Their aesthetically pleasing milkshakes have become synonymous with Instagram-friendly food, attracting attention from influencers and prompting visitors to snap and share photos of their decadent creations.


From its humble beginnings as a neighborhood burger joint to its current status as a global phenomenon, Black Tap has cemented its place in food travel culture. The rise of Black Tap serves as a testament to the power of creativity, quality ingredients, and the ever-present influence of social media in shaping culinary trends.


The Art of Milkshake Making

At Black Tap, creating a milkshake is not just about throwing some ice cream and milk together. It’s an art form that requires skill, creativity, and a genuine passion for delivering a memorable and indulgent experience for every customer.


One of the key elements that sets Black Tap’s milkshakes apart is the quality of the ingredients. They use homemade ice cream that is crafted in small batches to ensure maximum flavor and richness. The ice cream serves as the foundation for each milkshake, providing a creamy and luscious base that is the perfect canvas for the layering of flavors.


But it’s not just the ice cream that makes Black Tap’s milkshakes exceptional. It’s the attention to detail in every aspect of the shake. From the perfectly whipped and creamy texture to the precise measurements of each ingredient, every element is carefully considered to achieve the desired taste and consistency.


The mixologists at Black Tap take pride in their ability to create unique flavor combinations that tantalize the taste buds. They experiment with various ingredients, such as fresh fruits, chocolates, candies, and even savory elements, to create milkshakes that are both surprising and satisfying.


However, flavor is just one aspect of the art of milkshake making at Black Tap. The presentation is equally important. Each milkshake is adorned with a variety of eye-catching toppings, from whipped cream and sprinkles to cookies, marshmallows, and even whole slices of cake. These toppings not only add a visual appeal but also enhance the overall taste experience.


The final touch of artistry comes in the form of the milkshake’s presentation. Black Tap is known for its extravagant and Instagram-worthy milkshake designs. From towering, gravity-defying creations to milkshakes served in oversized glasses dripped with chocolate or caramel syrup, the presentation is an integral part of the milkshake experience at Black Tap.


Behind the scenes, the artists behind the milkshakes meticulously construct each layer, ensuring that every element is perfectly balanced and aesthetically pleasing. This attention to detail is evident in every shake that is served at Black Tap, creating a visual feast that is almost too beautiful to consume.


Overall, the art of milkshake making at Black Tap goes beyond just mixing ingredients. It is a harmonious blend of flavor, texture, presentation, and passion. Each milkshake created is a work of art that leaves a lasting impression on those lucky enough to indulge in one.


The Classic Milkshakes at Black Tap

While Black Tap is famous for its extravagant and over-the-top milkshakes, they also offer a selection of classic milkshakes that are a delightful nod to the traditional flavors we all know and love.


For those who appreciate the simplicity and timeless appeal of a classic milkshake, Black Tap has you covered. From the rich and creamy vanilla shake to the indulgent chocolate shake, these timeless favorites are expertly made with high-quality ingredients that elevate the classic flavors to a whole new level.


The vanilla milkshake at Black Tap is a true indulgence. Made with homemade vanilla ice cream, the shake is velvety smooth and bursting with that classic vanilla flavor. Each sip is like stepping back in time to the nostalgic days of old-fashioned soda fountains.


If you’re a chocolate lover, Black Tap’s chocolate milkshake is sure to satisfy your cravings. Made with their signature chocolate ice cream, this shake is rich, decadent, and downright delicious. The smooth chocolatey goodness is pure bliss with every sip.


In addition to the classic vanilla and chocolate, Black Tap also offers other staple flavors such as strawberry, caramel, and cookies and cream. Each shake is made with the utmost care and attention to detail, ensuring that every flavor shines through.


While these classic milkshakes may not have the extravagant toppings or elaborate presentations of their other creations, they are a testament to the skill and expertise of the team at Black Tap. They prove that sometimes simplicity can be just as satisfying, and that a perfectly executed classic milkshake can be a delightful indulgence.


So, the next time you visit Black Tap, don’t overlook their classic milkshakes. Whether you choose the vanilla, chocolate, or another timeless flavor, you’re in for a treat that will transport you back to simpler times while still delivering on the exceptional taste and quality that Black Tap is known for.


The Craziest Milkshakes on Black Tap’s Menu

While the classic milkshakes at Black Tap are delicious in their own right, it’s the crazier and more outrageous milkshakes that have garnered the most attention and made Black Tap a worldwide phenomenon.


One of the iconic milkshakes that put Black Tap on the map is the Cotton Candy Shake. This whimsical creation features a towering swirl of cotton candy perched on top of a milkshake filled with flavors like strawberry, vanilla, and even a hint of bubblegum. It’s a true feast for the senses, with the cotton candy adding a touch of sweetness and visually elevating the milkshake to a whole new level.


Another showstopper on Black Tap’s menu is the Sweet ‘N Salty Shake. This indulgent creation combines sweet and savory flavors in perfect harmony. The milkshake is a blend of creamy peanut butter and chocolate, topped with a generous helping of whipped cream, chocolate drizzle, and a chocolate-dipped pretzel rod. The combination of flavors and textures is a delightful surprise for your taste buds.


If you’re a fan of the classic childhood combination of peanut butter and jelly, then you’ll love the Peanut Butter Jelly Time Shake at Black Tap. This milkshake is a nostalgic throwback, featuring a creamy peanut butter shake with a generous dollop of jelly on top. It’s like a PB&J sandwich in liquid form.


For those who have a sweet tooth that knows no bounds, the Sweet Tooth Shake is a dream come true. This milkshake is a sugary wonderland, adorned with a slice of cake, a lollipop, and a mountain of whipped cream. With flavors like cotton candy, bubble gum, and marshmallow, this milkshake is a sugar rush waiting to happen.


If you’re a fan of chocolate, you won’t want to miss the Brooklyn Blackout Shake. Named after the infamous blackout cake, this decadent milkshake is made with rich chocolate ice cream, chocolate syrup, and brownie chunks. Topped with chocolate fudge, whipped cream, and a chocolate-dipped brownie, it’s a chocolate lover’s nirvana.


These are just a few examples of the craziest milkshakes you can find on Black Tap’s menu. They are indulgent, over-the-top, and guaranteed to satisfy even the most adventurous sweet tooth. The creativity and audacity that goes into each milkshake is a testament to the passion and innovation of the team at Black Tap.


So, whether you’re in the mood for a visually stunning cotton candy creation or a decadent peanut butter and chocolate concoction, Black Tap’s craziest milkshakes are sure to impress and leave you wanting more.


The Insta-Worthy Milkshakes

If you’re a social media-savvy foodie looking for the perfect Instagram-worthy shot, then look no further than the milkshakes at Black Tap. These photo-ready masterpieces are not only delicious but also visually stunning, making them a hit among influencers and food bloggers.


One of the most iconic insta-worthy milkshakes at Black Tap is the Birthday Cake Shake. This vibrant creation features a vanilla milkshake mixed with colorful cake batter and topped with a slice of funfetti cake, rainbow sprinkles, and a towering dollop of whipped cream. The explosion of colors and textures make it a feast for the eyes and the taste buds.


For those who love all things chocolate, the Chocolate Peppermint Shake is a must-try. This indulgent treat combines a rich chocolate shake with a chocolate-frosted rim coated in crushed candy canes. Topped with whipped cream and a chocolate peppermint bark, it’s a perfect seasonal treat that is as visually appealing as it is delicious.


If you’re in the mood for something tropical and refreshing, the Fruity Pebbles Shake is sure to catch your attention. This colorful creation combines a vanilla shake with fruity pebbles cereal, topped with a slice of rainbow-frosted rim and a generous heap of whipped cream. The vibrant colors and playful presentation make it a standout on any Instagram feed.


Black Tap’s milkshakes also showcase the flavors of the changing seasons. Their Pumpkin Pie Shake is a fall favorite, featuring a pumpkin spiced shake topped with a slice of homemade pumpkin pie and a dusting of cinnamon. With its warm hues and cozy presentation, it’s the perfect sip of autumn.


For those seeking a taste of summer, the Key Lime Pie Shake is a tropical delight. Made with a tangy key lime shake and topped with a slice of homemade key lime pie, whipped cream, and a sprinkle of crushed graham crackers, it’s like a vacation in a glass.


But perhaps the ultimate insta-worthy milkshake at Black Tap is their famous CrazyShake. These towering milkshakes feature a milkshake-filled mason jar adorned with an assortment of toppings, from cookies and candy to whole slices of cake and even cotton candy. The CrazyShakes are a sight to behold and have become synonymous with Black Tap’s over-the-top milkshake creations.


When it comes to capturing the perfect Instagram photo, Black Tap’s milkshakes are sure to impress. With their eye-catching colors, creative toppings, and imaginative presentations, they are a visual feast that will have your followers drooling and hitting that like button.


So grab your camera, choose your favorite milkshake from Black Tap’s menu, and get ready to capture the most insta-worthy shot that will have your followers asking, “Where can I get one of those?”.


A Taste of Black Tap’s Specialty Shakes

When you step into Black Tap, you’re not just entering a milkshake haven but also a world of specialty shakes that will leave you craving more. These unique creations take milkshakes to a whole new level, combining unexpected flavors, textures, and toppings that are guaranteed to tantalize your taste buds.


One of Black Tap’s most beloved specialty shakes is the Cookie Shake. This heavenly concoction takes your favorite cookies, crushes them up, and blends them into a creamy milkshake. From classic chocolate chip to indulgent Oreo, every sip is like biting into a cookie in liquid form. Topped with whipped cream and cookie crumbles, it’s a dessert lover’s dream come true.


If you’re a fan of peanut butter, the Peanut Butter Shake is a must-try specialty option. This rich and velvety shake is made with creamy peanut butter, mixed with vanilla ice cream, and topped with a generous drizzle of peanut butter sauce. It’s a peanut butter lover’s paradise that will keep you coming back for more.


Black Tap also offers a specialty shake that pays homage to one of New York City’s favorite desserts – the Cheesecake Shake. This decadent creation combines creamy cheesecake flavors with a smooth vanilla shake and is topped with a slice of New York-style cheesecake. It’s a true taste of the Big Apple in a glass.


For those looking for a tangy and refreshing option, the Key Lime Pie Shake is a specialty shake not to be missed. Bursting with the vibrant flavors of key lime, this shake is a perfect blend of tart and sweet. It’s topped with a slice of homemade key lime pie, whipped cream, and a sprinkle of crushed graham crackers, transporting you to a tropical paradise with each sip.


No discussion of Black Tap’s specialty shakes would be complete without mentioning the Coffee Shake. This indulgent creation combines the rich and bold flavors of coffee with creamy vanilla ice cream, resulting in a caffeinated delight. Topped with whipped cream and a drizzle of caramel, it’s the perfect shake to satisfy your coffee cravings.


These are just a sampling of the specialty shakes available at Black Tap. From the nostalgic taste of cookies to the creamy delight of cheesecake, each specialty shake offers a unique and unforgettable flavor experience. Each sip will transport you to a world of indulgence and leave you wanting more.


So, venture beyond the classics and discover the specialty shakes that Black Tap has to offer. Be prepared to embark on a taste journey like no other, where the boundaries of what a milkshake can be are pushed to new and delicious heights.


Black Tap’s Seasonal Milkshakes

One of the things that makes Black Tap unique is its commitment to offering seasonal milkshakes that celebrate the flavors and ingredients of each time of year. These limited-time offerings provide an opportunity for customers to experience the taste of the season in a truly indulgent and creative way.


During the winter months, Black Tap delights customers with holiday-inspired milkshakes that capture the festive spirit. The Peppermint Bark Shake, for example, combines the cool and refreshing flavors of mint with creamy chocolate ice cream. Topped with crushed peppermint candy and whipped cream, it’s like sipping on a cup of holiday cheer. Other winter specialties may include flavors like eggnog, gingerbread, or even a hot cocoa-inspired shake.


In the spring, Black Tap introduces milkshakes that showcase the vibrant and fresh flavors of the season. Fruit-inspired milkshakes like the Strawberry Shortcake Shake or the Mango Passion Shake make their appearance, featuring the sweetness of ripe berries or tropical fruits. These springtime delights are perfect for enjoying as the weather begins to warm up.


As the temperatures rise, Black Tap introduces milkshakes that are perfect for the summer heat. These seasonal offerings often include refreshing and fruity flavors like Watermelon, Coconut, or Pineapple. The vibrant and tropical ingredients transport you to a beachside paradise with each sip.


During the fall, Black Tap embraces the cozy and comforting flavors of the season. Pumpkin takes center stage in milkshakes like the Pumpkin Pie Shake or the Pumpkin Cheesecake Shake. These autumnal treats bring the taste of pumpkin spice and warm spices into a creamy milkshake that captures the essence of fall.


It’s worth noting that the availability of these seasonal milkshakes may vary, as they are only offered for a limited time. This adds an element of excitement and anticipation for visitors, as they wait for the announcement of the next seasonal shake to be released.


Black Tap’s seasonal milkshakes are a testament to their commitment to creativity and innovation. They showcase the culinary expertise of their team, as they skillfully incorporate seasonal ingredients and flavors into their milkshake creations. Each sip is a taste of the season, allowing customers to fully immerse themselves in the flavors and experiences that each time of year brings.


So, if you’re fortunate enough to visit Black Tap during a particular season, don’t miss out on the opportunity to try one of their seasonal milkshakes. It’s a chance to enjoy a unique and fleeting flavor experience that will surely leave you counting down the days until the next seasonal release.



Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer has become an iconic destination for food travelers seeking unforgettable milkshake experiences. From their classic milkshakes to their craziest creations, Black Tap’s dedication to flavor, presentation, and innovation has made them a global sensation.


The rise of Black Tap can be attributed to many factors — their imaginative milkshake designs, their commitment to using high-quality ingredients, and their ability to create a memorable and immersive experience for their customers. The art of milkshake making at Black Tap goes beyond just blending flavors; it’s a harmonious fusion of taste, presentation, and culinary craftsmanship.


Whether you’re sipping on a classic vanilla shake, indulging in one of their crazier creations, capturing the perfect Instagram-worthy shot, or enjoying a seasonal specialty shake, Black Tap offers something for everyone. Their menu is a testament to their creativity, their passion for pushing the boundaries of milkshake artistry, and their dedication to providing a delightful experience to every visitor.


So, if you find yourself in New York City or any of their other locations around the world, be sure to make a stop at Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer. Embark on a milkshake journey that will take your taste buds to new heights and leave you with memories that will last long after the last sip.


Black Tap has redefined the milkshake experience and continues to delight food travelers and milkshake enthusiasts alike. The combination of innovative flavors, eye-catching presentations, and a commitment to quality has solidified their place as a must-visit destination for those seeking an extraordinary and delicious food travel adventure.