Header Notice

Winter is here! Check out the winter wonderlands at these 5 amazing winter destinations in Montana

What Is The Difference Between An Adu And A Guest House?


by Jere Castillo




When it comes to finding accommodations for travelers, the options are diverse and can sometimes be confusing. Two popular choices that often come up in this context are Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) and guest houses. While both offer lodging for visitors, there are distinct differences between the two that are important to understand. Whether you’re a traveler seeking the perfect place to stay or a homeowner considering options for hosting guests, knowing the disparities between ADUs and guest houses can help you make informed decisions.


In this comprehensive guide, we’ll delve into the definitions of ADUs and guest houses, explore their key differences, consider the legal and zoning considerations associated with each, and weigh the pros and cons of both options. By the end of this article, you’ll have a clear understanding of what sets ADUs and guest houses apart, enabling you to make well-informed choices when it comes to accommodations and hosting guests.


Definition of an ADU

Definition of an ADU

An Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU), also known as a granny flat or mother-in-law suite, is a self-contained living space located on the same grounds as a single-family home. ADUs are equipped with their own entrance, kitchen, bathroom, and living area, providing complete autonomy for the occupants. These units can be either attached to the primary residence, such as a converted garage or basement, or detached, such as a standalone cottage or apartment above a garage.


ADUs are designed to function as separate living quarters and are typically used to accommodate extended family members, provide rental income, or offer a private living space for guests. They are known for their versatility and can serve as a long-term rental, short-term vacation rental, or a space for aging parents or adult children.


One of the key features of ADUs is their ability to blend into the existing neighborhood without significantly altering its character. They are often subject to local zoning and building regulations, which dictate their size, design, and permitted uses. These regulations vary by location and can influence the feasibility and requirements for constructing an ADU on a residential property.


Definition of a Guest House

Definition of a Guest House

A guest house, also referred to as a guest cottage or casita, is a separate residential structure located on the same property as the main dwelling. Unlike an ADU, a guest house is typically designed solely for accommodating visitors and does not necessarily contain full kitchen facilities. It may include a bedroom, bathroom, and living area, offering a comfortable and private space for guests to stay.


Guest houses are often utilized for short-term stays, providing a convenient and secluded lodging option for visitors. They can range in size and amenities, from a simple studio layout to a more spacious unit with multiple rooms. Some guest houses may feature basic kitchenette facilities, allowing guests to prepare simple meals and snacks during their stay.


While guest houses are intended to offer privacy and independence for guests, they are also subject to local regulations and zoning restrictions. The specific rules governing the construction and use of guest houses can vary by region and may impact factors such as size, occupancy limits, and rental arrangements.


Overall, guest houses serve as a dedicated space for hosting friends, family, or paying guests, providing a separate retreat while still being in close proximity to the main residence. Their design and functionality cater to the needs of temporary occupants, offering a balance of comfort and convenience during their stay.


Key Differences between an ADU and a Guest House

Key Differences between an ADU and a Guest House

While both ADUs and guest houses offer supplementary living spaces on residential properties, several distinct differences set them apart:

  • Primary Purpose: The primary purpose of an ADU is to provide a self-contained living space that can function as an independent residence. It may be used for long-term rental, accommodating family members, or serving as a private living space. In contrast, a guest house is specifically designed to host short-term visitors, offering a comfortable and private lodging option for guests.
  • Facilities: ADUs are equipped with full kitchen facilities, including a stove, refrigerator, and sink, allowing occupants to prepare meals and maintain a self-sufficient lifestyle. On the other hand, guest houses may feature limited kitchenette amenities, typically including a microwave, mini-fridge, and basic cooking facilities, suitable for short-term stays.
  • Autonomy: ADUs are designed to provide complete autonomy for their occupants, with a separate entrance and self-contained living amenities. This autonomy allows for long-term occupancy and independent living. In contrast, guest houses offer a degree of privacy and independence but are primarily tailored for temporary stays, with a focus on providing comfort and convenience for short-term guests.
  • Regulatory Considerations: The construction and use of ADUs are subject to specific zoning and building regulations, which can dictate factors such as size, occupancy limits, and permitted uses. Guest houses are also subject to local regulations, but their specific requirements may differ from those governing ADUs, particularly in terms of intended use and duration of occupancy.
  • Long-Term vs. Short-Term Use: ADUs are often utilized for long-term rental or extended family accommodations, offering a permanent living space that integrates with the main residence. Guest houses, on the other hand, cater to short-term visitors and are designed to provide a temporary, secluded retreat while maintaining proximity to the main dwelling.

Understanding these differences can help homeowners and travelers make informed decisions when considering accommodations or hosting guests, ensuring that the chosen living space aligns with the intended duration of stay and the level of autonomy and amenities required.


Legal and Zoning Considerations

Legal and Zoning Considerations

Both ADUs and guest houses are subject to legal and zoning considerations that can impact their construction, permitted uses, and compliance with local regulations. Understanding these considerations is crucial for homeowners and property owners looking to add supplementary living spaces to their residential properties.

  • Zoning Regulations: Local zoning ordinances dictate where ADUs and guest houses can be constructed, as well as the specific requirements they must meet. Zoning regulations may address factors such as setbacks from property lines, maximum allowable square footage, and the distinction between attached and detached units. It’s essential to review the zoning regulations in a specific area to determine the feasibility and requirements for adding an ADU or guest house to a property.
  • Building Codes: Both ADUs and guest houses are subject to building codes that govern their construction, safety standards, and habitability. These codes ensure that the supplementary living spaces meet structural and safety requirements, including considerations for electrical, plumbing, and overall structural integrity. Compliance with building codes is essential to obtain the necessary permits and approvals for constructing ADUs and guest houses.
  • Permitted Uses: Local regulations may outline the permitted uses of ADUs and guest houses, including whether they can be used for long-term rentals, short-term vacation rentals, or as accommodations for family members. Understanding the permitted uses can help homeowners determine how they can utilize these additional living spaces within the parameters of the law.
  • Rental Regulations: In some areas, there may be specific rental regulations that apply to ADUs and guest houses, particularly concerning short-term rentals through platforms such as Airbnb or VRBO. Homeowners considering renting out these supplementary living spaces should familiarize themselves with any rental restrictions or requirements imposed by local ordinances.

By taking these legal and zoning considerations into account, property owners can navigate the process of adding ADUs or guest houses to their residential properties in compliance with local regulations, ensuring that the additional living spaces are constructed and utilized within the parameters of the law.


Pros and Cons of ADU and Guest House

Pros and Cons of ADU and Guest House

When considering the addition of an ADU or guest house to a residential property, it’s essential to weigh the advantages and disadvantages associated with each option. Both ADUs and guest houses offer unique benefits and considerations that can influence the decision-making process for homeowners and property owners.


Pros of ADU:

  • Additional Rental Income: ADUs can serve as a source of additional rental income for homeowners, providing a separate living space that can be leased to tenants.
  • Extended Family Accommodations: ADUs offer the flexibility to accommodate extended family members, such as aging parents or adult children, while providing privacy and autonomy.
  • Property Value Enhancement: The addition of an ADU can potentially increase the overall property value, offering a desirable feature for prospective buyers.
  • Long-Term Rental Opportunities: ADUs can be utilized for long-term rentals, offering a stable and consistent income stream for homeowners.


Cons of ADU:

  • Construction Costs: Building or converting an ADU can involve significant upfront costs, including construction expenses and permit fees.
  • Zoning and Regulatory Hurdles: Navigating local zoning and regulatory requirements for ADUs can be complex and may present challenges for homeowners.
  • Maintenance and Management: Renting out an ADU requires ongoing maintenance and management responsibilities for homeowners, including tenant interactions and property upkeep.


Pros of Guest House:

  • Short-Term Rental Income: Guest houses provide an opportunity for homeowners to earn income through short-term rentals, catering to travelers and visitors.
  • Flexible Hosting Options: Homeowners can host friends, family, or paying guests in a separate and private space, offering convenience and independence.
  • Temporary Accommodations: Guest houses offer a comfortable and secluded lodging option for short-term visitors, enhancing the overall hospitality experience.


Cons of Guest House:

  • Regulatory Restrictions: Local regulations may impose limitations on the use of guest houses for short-term rentals, impacting the potential income-generating opportunities.
  • Initial Investment: Constructing or renovating a guest house involves initial investment costs, including construction expenses and necessary amenities.
  • Maintenance and Turnover: Managing a guest house for short-term rentals requires ongoing maintenance and turnovers between guests, adding to the homeowner's responsibilities.


By carefully considering the pros and cons of ADUs and guest houses, property owners can make informed decisions aligned with their goals, preferences, and the specific dynamics of their residential properties.




Understanding the distinctions between Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) and guest houses is essential for homeowners and travelers alike. Both options offer supplementary living spaces that cater to different needs and preferences, presenting unique advantages and considerations.


For homeowners seeking to expand their properties and accommodate guests or tenants, the decision between an ADU and a guest house hinges on factors such as long-term rental opportunities, regulatory compliance, and upfront investment. ADUs provide the flexibility to house extended family members, generate rental income, and potentially enhance property value, but they entail complex regulatory considerations and ongoing management responsibilities. On the other hand, guest houses offer convenient short-term lodging options for visitors and the potential for rental income through platforms like Airbnb, but they require careful adherence to local regulations and ongoing maintenance.


For travelers seeking accommodations, understanding the differences between ADUs and guest houses can inform their choices based on the duration of their stay, desired level of privacy, and access to amenities. ADUs offer complete autonomy and self-sufficiency for longer-term stays, while guest houses provide a secluded retreat for short-term visitors, often with the convenience of proximity to the main residence.


Ultimately, the decision to incorporate an ADU or guest house into a residential property involves careful consideration of the intended use, regulatory requirements, and financial implications. By weighing the pros and cons of each option, homeowners can make informed choices that align with their goals for hosting guests or generating rental income. Likewise, travelers can select accommodations that best suit their preferences and the nature of their stay, whether for an extended visit or a short-term getaway.


With a clear understanding of the distinctions between ADUs and guest houses, property owners and travelers can navigate the landscape of supplementary living spaces with confidence, ensuring that their choices align with their unique needs and the regulatory landscape of their respective locales.