Header Notice

Winter is here! Check out the winter wonderlands at these 5 amazing winter destinations in Montana

The Real Great Gatsby Is A Sandwich The Size Of A Baby Goat


Modified: January 3, 2024

by Linnell Marmolejo



Food travel is an enriching experience that allows us to explore different cultures, traditions, and flavors from around the world. It’s a journey that brings together the best of two worlds — the pleasure of traveling and the joy of indulging in delicious culinary creations.


One dish that has gained immense popularity among food enthusiasts and travelers alike is the iconic Great Gatsby sandwich. This colossal creation not only satisfies your hunger but also takes your taste buds on a flavor adventure.


The origins of the Great Gatsby sandwich trace back to New Jersey, where it was first introduced in the early 20th century. This massive sandwich quickly became a local legend, gaining a cult following among locals and travelers seeking a truly memorable gastronomic experience.


What sets the Great Gatsby sandwich apart is its sheer size and eclectic combination of ingredients. From succulent meat to tangy condiments and crispy veggies, every bite is a medley of flavors and textures that leave a lasting impression.


Embarking on a food travel journey to taste the Great Gatsby sandwich is an opportunity to immerse yourself in the history and culture of the region. It serves as a gateway to exploring the local culinary scene, where you can discover unique and authentic flavors that reflect the essence of the destination.


In this article, we will delve into the origins and intricacies of the Great Gatsby sandwich. We will uncover the ingredients that make it a true culinary masterpiece and walk you through the process of creating this mouthwatering delight. So, get ready for a delectable adventure as we embark on a food travel experience like no other with the Great Gatsby sandwich!


The Origins of the Great Gatsby Sandwich

The story behind the Great Gatsby sandwich is just as intriguing as its name. Contrary to what one might assume, its origins are not tied to the characters or setting of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s renowned novel. Instead, this culinary masterpiece hails from New Jersey, where it emerged as a beloved local delicacy in the early 20th century.


The exact origin of the Great Gatsby sandwich is shrouded in mystery, with several establishments claiming to be its birthplace. One popular theory suggests that it was first crafted in a small deli in Long Branch, a coastal town located in Monmouth County, New Jersey. The deli, known as Gatsby’s on the Ocean, is said to have created this monumental sandwich to cater to the appetites of beachgoers and hungry locals.


Another theory credits the creation of the Great Gatsby sandwich to another local establishment called the White House Sub Shop. This eatery, located in Atlantic City, has been serving up mouthwatering subs and sandwiches since 1946. According to their claim, the Great Gatsby sandwich was their brainchild, specially crafted to cater to the hearty appetite of New Jersey residents and visitors.


Regardless of its precise origin, the Great Gatsby sandwich quickly became a beloved icon in the local culinary scene. Its reputation spread like wildfire, drawing in food enthusiasts from all corners of the state and beyond. Over time, the sandwich caught the attention of famous personalities and celebrities who couldn’t resist trying this massive creation.


It’s worth noting that the origin of the name “Great Gatsby” for this sandwich is a subject of debate. Some speculate that it was named after F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel as a nod to the extravagant and lavish lifestyle depicted in the story. Others believe that it was simply a catchy name that evoked curiosity and excitement among customers.


Today, the Great Gatsby sandwich has become a legendary dish, synonymous with the culinary culture of New Jersey. It is not only enjoyed by locals but also sought after by food travelers who are eager to experience this gastronomic marvel. Its origins, although somewhat clouded, have added to the intrigue and allure surrounding this colossal sandwich.


Unveiling the Ingredients

What makes the Great Gatsby sandwich truly exceptional are the carefully chosen ingredients that come together to create a symphony of flavors. Each component plays a vital role in crafting this culinary masterpiece, offering a delightful blend of textures and tastes.


The foundation of the Great Gatsby sandwich is typically a generous selection of deli meats. Thinly sliced corned beef, pastrami, turkey, and roast beef are often layered upon one another, ensuring a mouthwatering abundance of savory flavors. These succulent meats are perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection, adding a rich and satisfying element to the sandwich.


To complement the meats, a variety of cheeses are added, providing that perfect melt-in-your-mouth experience. From Swiss and provolone to cheddar and American cheese, the choice of cheese can vary based on personal preference. The creamy and slightly salty nature of the cheese elevates the overall flavor profile of the sandwich.


No sandwich is complete without condiments, and the Great Gatsby delivers in this department. Tangy mustard, zesty mayonnaise, and classic Russian dressing are common condiments used to enhance the taste. These spreadable delights add a burst of flavor and balance the richness of the meats and cheese.


Another crucial element of the Great Gatsby sandwich is the crunchy and refreshing assortment of vegetables. Crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, and flavorful pickles create a beautiful textural contrast and provide a fresh and vibrant component to the sandwich. Additional toppings like onions, peppers, and olives can also be incorporated to add even more depth to the flavor profile.


The final touch comes in the form of freshly baked bread. The choice of bread can vary, but some popular options include crusty Italian or French bread, hoagie rolls, or a hearty rye bread. This sturdy vehicle holds all the ingredients together, allowing you to savor each delicious bite without worrying about any structural mishaps.


While the core ingredients of the Great Gatsby sandwich remain consistent, many variations and personal twists have emerged over the years. Some adventurous individuals may choose to add bacon or avocado, while others might opt for a spicy kick with jalapenos or hot sauce. These adaptations only add to the excitement and endless possibilities of enjoying this culinary marvel.


So, whether you prefer a traditional approach or enjoy experimenting with different flavors, the Great Gatsby sandwich is sure to satisfy your cravings. Its combination of delectable meats, cheeses, condiments, vegetables, and bread is what truly sets it apart and makes it a must-try for any food traveler.


The Sandwich Making Process

The Great Gatsby sandwich is not only known for its remarkable combination of ingredients but also for its impressive size. Assembling this colossal creation requires careful precision and a bit of finesse. Here is a glimpse into the sandwich making process that brings this culinary masterpiece to life.


First, start by selecting the bread for your Great Gatsby sandwich. Choose a substantial bread that can hold up to the generous amount of fillings. Slice it lengthwise, creating a sturdy foundation for the layers of ingredients to come.


Next, gather your deli meats of choice. Thinly slice corned beef, pastrami, turkey, and roast beef, piling them on top of one another to create a substantial stack. Spread your desired condiments generously on the bread – tangy mustard, zesty mayonnaise, or Russian dressing – ensuring every bite is full of flavor.


Now comes the time to layer on the cheeses. Add slices of Swiss, provolone, cheddar, or American cheese, allowing them to melt slightly from the heat of the freshly cooked meats. This adds an incredible richness to the sandwich.


After the cheese, it’s time to add an explosion of freshness. Layer on crisp lettuce, juicy tomato slices, and flavorful pickles. Don’t be afraid to add additional toppings like onions, peppers, or olives to personalize your sandwich further.


Finish off the layers with another generous helping of deli meat, creating a towering masterpiece. Close the sandwich with the top half of the bread, pressing down gently to bring all the ingredients together.


Now comes the moment of truth – slicing the Great Gatsby sandwich. Using a sharp knife, carefully cut it into manageable portions. The sandwich can be cut into halves, quarters, or even into small slider-sized servings.


With the sandwich successfully sliced, it’s time to admire your creation and marvel at its size and mouthwatering appearance. The multiple layers of meats, cheeses, condiments, and vegetables sandwiched between the bread are a true testament to the art of culinary craftsmanship.


Now, sit back, relax, and prepare to savor every mouthful of this colossal creation. You may want to enlist the help of friends or family to fully enjoy this monster-sized sandwich. Share the experience, and let the flavors explode in your mouth with each bite.


Remember, the Great Gatsby sandwich is not just a meal — it’s an experience. So, embrace the process, savor the flavors, and revel in the joy of indulging in this incredible culinary creation.


Size Matters: Comparing the Great Gatsby Sandwich to a Baby Goat

When it comes to the Great Gatsby sandwich, size is a defining characteristic. This colossal creation is known for its impressive dimensions, often leaving diners in awe of its sheer magnitude. To truly grasp the enormity of this sandwich, let’s compare it to the size of a baby goat.


A typical Great Gatsby sandwich measures anywhere from 12 to 24 inches in length, depending on the establishment and its variation. The width can range from 6 to 8 inches, resembling the size of a small loaf of bread. This means that the sandwich is not only lengthy but also substantial in its girth.


On the other hand, a baby goat, also known as a kid, can measure 20 to 25 inches in height and weigh around 25 to 35 pounds. Although smaller in size compared to an adult goat, a baby goat still presents a considerable size that is worth noting.


When comparing the size of the Great Gatsby sandwich to a baby goat, it becomes evident that the sandwich can rival the dimensions of this adorable farm animal. The sheer scale of the sandwich is a testament to the creativity and culinary prowess required to craft such a masterpiece.


However, it is important to note that while the Great Gatsby sandwich may be comparable in size to a baby goat, the sandwich is a gastronomic delight meant to be savored and enjoyed, while a baby goat is an adorable creature that brings joy in different ways.


The size of the Great Gatsby sandwich is not just for show; it serves a practical purpose as well. Its massive proportions allow for a delightful sharing experience among groups of friends or family. This sandwich easily becomes the centerpiece of any gathering, sparking conversations and creating lasting memories.


Moreover, the size of the Great Gatsby sandwich embodies the spirit of indulgence and abundance. It symbolizes an opportunity to truly relish in a decadent meal, to satisfy one’s hunger and culinary desires. It serves as a reminder that sometimes, bigger is indeed better.


So, whether you marvel at the grandeur of the Great Gatsby sandwich or delight in the charming presence of a baby goat, both hold their own place in our hearts. Both bring joy, whether through food or the wonders of nature. Size may matter in this comparison, but it is ultimately the experiences and emotions they evoke that make them truly remarkable.


The Great Gatsby Effect: Its Impact on Food Culture

The Great Gatsby sandwich isn’t just a culinary masterpiece; it has also had a significant impact on food culture. This colossal creation has become a symbol of indulgence, innovation, and the ability to push the boundaries of what a sandwich can be. Let’s explore the Great Gatsby effect and its influence on food culture.


First and foremost, the Great Gatsby sandwich has captured the imagination of food enthusiasts around the world. Its impressive size and tantalizing combination of ingredients have made it a viral sensation on social media platforms, inspiring food lovers to seek out this gastronomic marvel. Countless photos, videos, and reviews have contributed to the sandwich’s legendary status, spreading the word and fueling its popularity.


With its rise to fame, the Great Gatsby sandwich has sparked a wave of creativity among chefs and sandwich aficionados. It has become a source of inspiration for culinary experimentation, prompting chefs to reimagine traditional sandwiches and push the boundaries of flavor combinations and presentation.


This trend has led to the emergence of new variations of the Great Gatsby sandwich, each with its own unique twist. Some establishments opt for different types of bread, while others introduce unconventional ingredients, bold flavors, or specialized regional influences. This culinary innovation has breathed new life into the sandwich genre, elevating it to new heights.


The Great Gatsby sandwich has also had a profound impact on the dining experience itself. It has redefined the notion of what a sandwich can offer, transforming it from a simple grab-and-go meal into a centerpiece that demands attention and celebration. Sharing a Great Gatsby sandwich with friends or family has become a communal experience, fostering a sense of togetherness and creating memorable moments.


Furthermore, the popularity of the Great Gatsby sandwich has contributed to the growth and recognition of local food establishments. As news travels of the incredible sandwiches being served, people actively seek them out, leading to increased patronage and exposure for these businesses. This has created a positive ripple effect on the local economy and culinary landscape, helping to promote and preserve local food culture.


It is important to note that the Great Gatsby effect goes beyond the world of sandwiches. It epitomizes the power of innovation and passion in the culinary arts. By breaking away from convention and embracing creativity, chefs and food lovers are reminded of the endless possibilities that exist within the world of gastronomy.


The impact of the Great Gatsby sandwich on food culture serves as a powerful reminder that food is more than just sustenance; it is a bridge that connects people, cultures, and experiences. It is a celebration of creativity, flavor, and shared moments. With its impressive size, unique flavors, and ability to captivate our senses, the Great Gatsby sandwich continues to leave an indelible mark on the ever-evolving landscape of food culture.



The Great Gatsby sandwich is more than just a sandwich; it is a culinary icon that has captured the hearts, appetites, and imaginations of food enthusiasts around the world. Its colossal size, delectable combination of ingredients, and impact on food culture make it an unforgettable experience for those fortunate enough to embark on a food travel journey to taste it.


From its mysterious origins in New Jersey to its viral status on social media platforms, the Great Gatsby sandwich has become a symbol of indulgence and innovation. It has inspired creativity among chefs and sandwich enthusiasts, leading to new variations and the exploration of unique flavors and textures.


The sandwich-making process showcases the care and craftsmanship that goes into creating this formidable masterpiece. The towering layers of meats, cheeses, condiments, and vegetables are a testament to the artistry of culinary creation and the joy of sharing a delicious meal with loved ones.


Size matters when it comes to the Great Gatsby sandwich. Its impressive proportions rival the stature of a baby goat, while its ability to bring people together and spark conversations creates lasting memories. The Great Gatsby sandwich is not just a meal; it is an experience, a celebration of abundance and the pursuit of culinary excellence.


Its impact on food culture is undeniable. It has redefined the boundaries of what a sandwich can be, inspired culinary innovation, and brought recognition to local food establishments. It serves as a reminder of the power of creativity and passion in the culinary arts, encouraging us to embrace endless possibilities and celebrate the rich diversity of flavors and experiences that food brings.


In conclusion, the Great Gatsby sandwich is a true gem in the world of food travel. Its origins, ingredients, size, and impact on food culture all contribute to its legendary status. So, whether you embark on a quest to taste this culinary masterpiece or simply marvel at its prominence, the Great Gatsby sandwich will continue to inspire and delight for generations to come.