Header Notice

Winter is here! Check out the winter wonderlands at these 5 amazing winter destinations in Montana

Prohibition Bakery – Craft Cocktail Cupcakes | Jessie On A Journey


Modified: December 27, 2023

by Ofella Haugh



Food and travel enthusiasts are always on the lookout for unique and exciting culinary experiences. Whether it’s exploring local cuisines or indulging in delicious desserts, there’s always something new and enticing to discover. For those with an adventurous sweet tooth, Prohibition Bakery is a hidden gem that combines the best of both worlds – craft cocktails and cupcakes.


Located in the heart of New York City, Prohibition Bakery has gained a loyal following for its innovative twist on traditional cupcakes. With a menu inspired by classic and contemporary craft cocktails, this bakery offers a truly one-of-a-kind experience that will leave you craving for more.


Established in 2011 by Brooke Siem and Leslie Feinberg, Prohibition Bakery was born out of a passion for baking and mixology. The duo wanted to create a space where they could blend their love for cocktails and cupcakes, and thus, Prohibition Bakery was born.


At Prohibition Bakery, the focus is on quality and creativity. Every cupcake is lovingly handcrafted using high-quality ingredients, resulting in tantalizing flavors that are sure to impress even the most discerning palates. From traditional favorites to unique concoctions, there’s a cupcake to satisfy every craving.


So, if you’re someone who enjoys sipping on a perfectly crafted cocktail and indulging in a delectable dessert, Prohibition Bakery is the place to be. With its charming ambiance, friendly staff, and mouthwatering cupcakes, this bakery is a must-visit destination for food travelers looking to embark on a sweet and boozy adventure.


The Concept of Prohibition Bakery

Prohibition Bakery brings together two seemingly unrelated worlds – craft cocktails and cupcakes – to create a unique and unforgettable experience. The concept behind this bakery is to infuse the flavors and essence of craft cocktails into the form of a cupcake, resulting in a delightful and innovative treat.


The idea of Prohibition Bakery stems from the rich history of the Prohibition era in the United States. This period, which lasted from 1920 to 1933, prohibited the sale and consumption of alcoholic beverages. However, it also gave rise to the speakeasy culture, where hidden bars and secret venues served bootlegged cocktails to eager patrons. Prohibition Bakery aims to capture the essence of this rebellious and clandestine era through their craft cocktail-inspired cupcakes.


Brooke Siem and Leslie Feinberg, the founders of Prohibition Bakery, wanted to create a bakery that reflected their love for both mixology and baking. By combining the art of creating craft cocktails with the science of baking, they were able to develop a unique concept that has captured the hearts and taste buds of food enthusiasts.


The bakery offers an ever-changing menu of cupcakes, with flavors inspired by classic and contemporary craft cocktails. From the smoky notes of a Manhattan to the tangy freshness of a Mojito, each cupcake is carefully crafted to mimic the taste profile of its cocktail counterpart. This attention to detail and commitment to providing an authentic experience sets Prohibition Bakery apart from traditional cupcake shops.


Furthermore, Prohibition Bakery is not just about the flavors. The presentation of the cupcakes is also taken into consideration, with beautifully decorated creations that are visually appealing. From intricate swirls of frosting to delicate garnishes, every cupcake is a work of art that enhances the overall experience.


Whether you are a fan of craft cocktails or simply have a sweet tooth, Prohibition Bakery offers a unique concept that appeals to a wide range of tastes. It is a place where the worlds of mixology and baking collide to create a truly unforgettable culinary adventure.


The Unique Combination of Craft Cocktails and Cupcakes

Prohibition Bakery stands out from traditional bakeries by offering a truly unique combination – craft cocktails and cupcakes. This innovative pairing delights customers who appreciate both the art of mixology and the sweetness of cupcakes. The fusion of these two worlds creates a harmonious blend of flavors and experiences that cannot be found elsewhere.


What sets Prohibition Bakery apart is their dedication to capturing the essence of craft cocktails in each cupcake. The flavors are carefully crafted to mimic the intricate taste profiles of classic and contemporary cocktails. With every bite, you can taste the complex layers of flavors that make craft cocktails so enjoyable.


Imagine indulging in a cupcake infused with the smoky essence of a classic Old Fashioned or the zing of a fresh Margarita. The velvety richness of a chocolate cupcake combined with the boldness of a Negroni creates a truly extraordinary treat. Each cupcake is like a miniature cocktail, providing a unique and indulgent experience.


Additionally, the texture and presentation of the cupcakes at Prohibition Bakery further enhance the overall experience. The pillowy softness of the cake, the creamy frosting, and the decorative garnishes all contribute to a feast for the senses. It’s not just about the taste; it’s about the visual appeal and the pleasure of savoring every bite.


For those who are passionate about craft cocktails, Prohibition Bakery offers a new way to enjoy their favorite libations. It allows customers to explore familiar flavors in a different form and to indulge in their love for cocktail culture in a whole new way. It’s an opportunity to experience the creativity and expertise of mixology in a delicious and accessible manner.


Moreover, the combination of craft cocktails and cupcakes opens up a world of possibilities for pairing and experimenting with flavors. Customers can choose to enjoy a cupcake alongside its cocktail counterpart, creating a harmonious and complementary taste experience. The flavors can play off each other, enhancing the overall enjoyment and providing a unique twist on traditional pairings.


Overall, the unique combination of craft cocktails and cupcakes at Prohibition Bakery offers a delightful and exciting culinary adventure. It appeals to those who appreciate the artistry of mixology and the indulgence of sweet treats. It’s a concept that brings together two beloved worlds and creates a truly memorable experience for food and travel enthusiasts alike.


The Creative Flavors Offered

One of the highlights of visiting Prohibition Bakery is the wide array of creative flavors on offer. Each cupcake is a delicious masterpiece, meticulously designed to capture the essence of various craft cocktails. From classic favorites to their own unique creations, the flavors at Prohibition Bakery never fail to surprise and delight.


For those who appreciate the classics, there are cupcakes inspired by timeless cocktails like the Old Fashioned, Mojito, and Margarita. Indulge in the rich flavors of bourbon and citrus in the Old Fashioned cupcake, or enjoy the refreshing combination of mint and lime in the Mojito cupcake. The Margarita cupcake combines the tanginess of lime with a hint of tequila, creating a mini fiesta for your taste buds.


In addition to the classics, Prohibition Bakery also offers inventive and unexpected flavors that showcase the bakery’s creativity. How about trying the Dark & Stormy cupcake, infused with the bold flavors of ginger beer and rum? Or the Champagne & Rose petal cupcake, an elegant treat that embodies celebration and romance?


But the creativity doesn’t stop there. Prohibition Bakery is known for their seasonal flavors that reflect the changing tastes and ingredients of each time of year. From pumpkin spice in the fall to refreshing fruity flavors in the summer, there’s always something new and exciting to try.


For those with a taste for adventure, Prohibition Bakery even offers alcoholic cupcake flavors that pack an extra punch. The Boozy Brunch cupcake, for example, combines the flavors of bourbon, orange juice, and coffee liqueur, creating a breakfast-inspired delight. These cupcakes are perfect for those who want to take their cocktail and dessert experience to the next level.


What sets Prohibition Bakery apart is their commitment to using high-quality ingredients and innovative flavor combinations. Each cupcake is lovingly crafted to ensure that every bite is a burst of flavor. The bakery’s dedication to creativity and attention to detail make their flavors stand out amongst the competition.


Whether you prefer classic cocktails or crave adventurous flavor combinations, Prohibition Bakery has something for everyone. Each visit is an opportunity to explore new taste sensations and indulge in a truly unique and flavorful experience.


The Process of Baking Craft Cocktail Cupcakes

Baking craft cocktail cupcakes is a meticulous and creative process that requires a unique approach. At Prohibition Bakery, the bakers go above and beyond to ensure that each cupcake captures the spirit and flavors of its corresponding cocktail.


It all starts with the selection of high-quality ingredients. The bakers meticulously source the finest ingredients, from the flour and sugar to the premium spirits and fresh fruits. This commitment to quality ensures that the cupcakes not only taste delicious but also reflect the authenticity of the cocktails they are inspired by.


Once the ingredients are gathered, the bakers begin by creating the base batter for the cupcakes. This involves carefully measuring and combining the dry ingredients, such as flour, baking powder, and salt, with the wet ingredients, including butter, eggs, and milk. The result is a velvety and flavorful cake mixture that forms the foundation of each cupcake.


The next step is where the magic happens – infusing the cupcakes with the distinct flavors of the craft cocktails. The bakers draw inspiration from the cocktail’s ingredients and incorporate them into the cupcake batter. For example, for a margarita-inspired cupcake, they might add freshly squeezed lime juice and a dash of tequila. This infusion ensures that the cupcakes have a true representation of the cocktail’s taste profile.


Once the batter is flavored, it is divided into individual cupcake liners and placed in the oven to bake. The bakers carefully monitor the baking process to ensure that each cupcake is baked to perfection, with a moist and fluffy texture that melts in your mouth.


While the cupcakes are baking, the bakers prepare the frosting and garnishes. Just like the cake batter, the frostings are meticulously crafted to mimic the flavors of the accompanying cocktails. From a creamy bourbon-infused frosting to a tangy citrus buttercream, the frostings add an extra layer of flavor and decadence to the cupcakes.


Once the cupcakes have cooled, it’s time for the final touch – the frosting and garnishing. The bakers expertly pipe swirls of frosting onto each cupcake, creating beautiful designs and ensuring an even distribution of flavor. They may also garnish the cupcakes with edible decorations, such as dried fruit, chocolate shavings, or cocktail-inspired garnishes like mini cocktail umbrellas or sugar rims.


The result is a visually stunning cupcake that not only captures the essence of a craft cocktail but also satisfies the sweet tooth of anyone who takes a bite. Each cupcake is a labor of love, showcasing the skill and dedication of the bakers at Prohibition Bakery.


Whether it’s infusing the batter with authentic flavors or crafting the perfect frosting, the process of baking craft cocktail cupcakes requires precision and creativity. It’s a testament to the bakery’s commitment to providing a unique and delightful experience for their customers.


Pairing Craft Cocktail Cupcakes with Real Cocktails

One of the unique aspects of the Prohibition Bakery experience is the opportunity to pair their craft cocktail cupcakes with real cocktails. This brings the concept of the bakery to a whole new level, allowing customers to enjoy a complete and harmonious tasting experience.


The art of pairing cocktails and cupcakes lies in finding complementary flavors and textures that enhance and elevate the overall tasting experience. Just as a sommelier pairs wine with food, Prohibition Bakery has perfected the art of matching cupcakes with cocktails.


For example, if you’re enjoying a Moscow Mule cupcake, you might opt for a classic Moscow Mule cocktail to accompany it. The cupcake’s ginger and lime flavors can harmonize with the cocktail’s refreshing and zesty notes, creating a symphony of taste on your palate.


Similarly, the rich and smoky flavors of an Old Fashioned cupcake can be beautifully balanced by sipping on an actual Old Fashioned cocktail. The cupcake’s bourbon-infused cake and bittersweet frosting can be enhanced when enjoyed alongside the cocktail’s complex blend of whiskey, sugar, and aromatic bitters.


Pairing craft cocktail cupcakes with real cocktails allows for a sensory experience that takes your taste buds on a journey. It’s an opportunity to explore the flavors in multiple dimensions and discover how different elements of taste can interact and enhance each other.


When it comes to pairing, there are no hard and fast rules. It’s all about experimenting and finding combinations that you personally enjoy. You may choose to match similar flavors, such as a mojito cupcake with an actual mojito, or you might decide to contrast flavors, like a fruity cupcake with a smoky whiskey cocktail.


The staff at Prohibition Bakery are experts in suggesting pairings and are always ready to guide and assist customers in their tasting adventures. They can recommend cocktails that will complement the cupcakes’ flavors and enhance the overall experience.


Pairing craft cocktail cupcakes with real cocktails not only enhances the taste experience but also adds a sense of fun and excitement. It’s a chance to step into the world of mixology and indulge in the art of cocktail creation alongside your cupcake indulgence.


So, the next time you visit Prohibition Bakery, be sure to explore the world of pairings. Experiment with different combinations, unleash your taste buds, and let the flavors of cupcakes and cocktails intertwine for a truly phenomenal tasting journey.


Enjoying Craft Cocktail Cupcakes at Prohibition Bakery

Visiting Prohibition Bakery is not just about indulging in delicious cupcakes; it’s about embarking on a culinary adventure and experiencing a unique blend of flavors. From the moment you step into the bakery, you are greeted with an inviting atmosphere that exudes charm and nostalgia.


The warm and welcoming staff at Prohibition Bakery are passionate about their craft and eager to guide you through their menu of craft cocktail-inspired cupcakes. They will gladly explain the flavors, offer pairing suggestions, and provide recommendations based on your preferences.


Once you’ve made your selection, you can choose to enjoy your cupcakes and cocktails in the cozy seating area inside the bakery. The intimate setting allows you to savor each bite and sip in a relaxed and comfortable environment, immersing yourself in the flavors and ambiance of Prohibition Bakery.


As you take your first bite of a craft cocktail cupcake, you’ll experience an explosion of flavors dancing on your palate. The moist and flavorful cake, paired with the creamy and luscious frosting, creates a combination that is nothing short of divine. Each bite reveals the careful infusion of craft cocktail elements, transporting you to a world of indulgence and culinary delight.


One of the joys of enjoying craft cocktail cupcakes at Prohibition Bakery is the element of surprise. With an ever-changing menu, you can always look forward to new flavors and combinations. The bakery’s commitment to creativity ensures that each visit will be a unique and exciting experience.


Aside from the cupcakes themselves, Prohibition Bakery also offers a selection of non-alcoholic beverages, such as coffee and tea, to complement your dessert. These beverages provide a refreshing contrast to the rich flavors of the cupcakes and can further enhance your overall enjoyment.


After your visit, you’ll find yourself yearning to return to Prohibition Bakery to explore more of their enticing flavors. The experience of enjoying craft cocktail cupcakes at this bakery is truly unforgettable, leaving you with a longing to relive the decadence and creativity that permeates every bite.


Prohibition Bakery has gained recognition not only for its exceptional cupcakes but also for its commitment to customer satisfaction. The bakery takes pride in creating a memorable experience for each and every visitor, ensuring that every cupcake is made with passion, precision, and a touch of magic.


So, whether you’re a local looking for a unique dessert experience or a food traveler seeking a taste of something extraordinary, a visit to Prohibition Bakery is a must. Prepare to indulge in exquisitely crafted cupcakes, experience the thrill of flavors inspired by craft cocktails, and embark on a journey of sweet and boozy bliss.


Social Media Buzz and Customer Reviews

Prohibition Bakery has garnered a significant following on social media, with customers raving about their craft cocktail cupcakes. Platforms such as Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter are abuzz with mouthwatering photos and glowing reviews of the bakery’s unique creations.


Customers often take to social media to share their delightful experiences at Prohibition Bakery. They post pictures of their beautifully decorated cupcakes, capturing the vibrant colors and intricate designs. These visually appealing images create a buzz and entice others to visit the bakery and try the cupcakes for themselves.


In addition to the captivating visuals, customers also express their satisfaction through heartfelt reviews and comments. They praise the bakery for its innovative concept, highlighting the exceptional craftsmanship and attention to detail put into each cupcake. Many customers, both locals and tourists, appreciate the combination of craft cocktails and cupcakes and applaud Prohibition Bakery for its creativity.


The unique flavors offered by Prohibition Bakery are often the subject of discussion among food enthusiasts on social media. Customers love discovering new taste sensations and eagerly share their favorite cupcake flavors and pairings. This lively online conversation serves as a testament to the bakery’s ability to captivate the taste buds and create a memorable experience.


Word of mouth also plays a significant role in spreading the buzz about Prohibition Bakery. Customers who have had the pleasure of tasting their craft cocktail cupcakes often recommend the bakery to friends and family, both online and offline. This organic promotion speaks volumes about the quality and appeal of the cupcakes.


It’s not just customers who are raving about Prohibition Bakery; media outlets and influencers have also taken notice. The bakery has been featured in numerous publications and blogs, with articles praising the delectable cupcakes and unique concept. Influencers and food bloggers frequently visit Prohibition Bakery, documenting their experiences and sharing their love for the bakery’s irresistible treats with their followers.


Prohibition Bakery’s strong presence on social media and the positive customer reviews highlight the bakery’s success in creating a loyal and passionate fan base. The combination of mesmerizing visuals, captivating flavors, and exceptional customer service has propelled the bakery into the spotlight, solidifying its reputation as a must-visit destination for food travelers and dessert connoisseurs alike.


Whether it’s the alluring images on Instagram or the heartfelt reviews on Facebook, the social media buzz surrounding Prohibition Bakery is a testament to the bakery’s ability to create a captivating culinary experience. It’s a testament to the bakery’s commitment to quality, creativity, and the art of combining craft cocktails and cupcakes.



Prohibition Bakery has carved a unique niche in the world of desserts with its craft cocktail-inspired cupcakes. Combining the art of mixology with the science of baking, this bakery offers an extraordinary culinary experience that captivates the taste buds and leaves a lasting impression.


From the concept of infusing craft cocktail flavors into cupcakes to the meticulous process of baking and the delightful pairing options, Prohibition Bakery has crafted a truly immersive and innovative dessert experience. The bakery’s dedication to using high-quality ingredients and the creative flavors they offer sets them apart from traditional cupcake shops.


The combination of craft cocktails and cupcakes at Prohibition Bakery not only tantalizes the taste buds but also evokes a sense of nostalgia and adventure. Each bite transports you to a bygone era, with flavors reminiscent of the Prohibition era’s clandestine bars and hidden speakeasies.


The social media buzz surrounding Prohibition Bakery, along with glowing customer reviews, attests to the bakery’s ability to create a captivating and unforgettable experience. From the visually stunning cupcake designs to the mouthwatering flavors and the passion of the staff, every aspect of Prohibition Bakery reflects their commitment to excellence.


Whether you’re a local resident or a food traveler exploring New York City, a visit to Prohibition Bakery is a must. It’s an opportunity to indulge in the unique combination of craft cocktails and cupcakes, to savor the creative flavors, and to immerse yourself in a culinary adventure like no other.


Prohibition Bakery has successfully merged two beloved worlds – mixology and baking – creating a destination that captivates both cocktail enthusiasts and dessert lovers. With each visit, you’ll be treated to a symphony of flavors, craftsmanship, and pure indulgence.


So, if you’re ready to tantalize your taste buds, step into the world of Prohibition Bakery. Be prepared for an explosion of flavors, a journey through cocktail-inspired cupcakes, and an experience that will leave you craving for more.