Betty's Pies, Rustic Inn Café, and New Scenic Café are the North Shore's true hidden pie gems, while Pie Place Cafe & Bakery in Grand Marais is the only other spot on this list with a documented pie pedigree. These four are the ones worth going out of your way for, with Betty's leading the pack since the 1950s.
Hidden Gems for Pie Lovers
Minnesota's North Shore is known for its stunning landscapes, but it's also home to some of the best pie shops. Tucked away in charming towns and scenic spots, these pie shops offer treats that are worth the trip.
1. Betty's Pies
Betty's Pies has been a North Shore staple since the 1950s. Originally a fish shack, it transformed into a pie shop that locals and tourists alike adore.
- Location: Two Harbors
- Must-Try: Five-Layer Chocolate Pie
- Fun Fact: Betty's Pies started with just one pie recipe and now boasts over 30 varieties.
2. Rustic Inn Café
Rustic Inn Café offers a cozy atmosphere and pies that taste like home. This family-owned spot is perfect for a comforting slice after a day of exploring.
- Location: Castle Danger
- Must-Try: Maple Pecan Pie
- Fun Fact: The café uses locally sourced ingredients to ensure the freshest flavors.
3. New Scenic Café
New Scenic Café combines gourmet dining with incredible pies. Known for its innovative menu, this café's pies are a delightful surprise.
- Location: Duluth
- Must-Try: Blueberry Lemon Pie
- Fun Fact: The café's chef often experiments with seasonal ingredients, making each visit unique.
4. Pie Place Cafe & Bakery
Pie Place Cafe & Bakery is a must-visit for anyone traveling through Grand Marais. With a wide variety of pies, this café has something for everyone.
- Location: Grand Marais
- Must-Try: Raspberry Rhubarb Pie
5. Judy's Café
Judy's Café is a hidden gem in Two Harbors. Known for its friendly service and delicious pies, this café is a local favorite.
- Location: Two Harbors
- Must-Try: Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
- Fun Fact: Judy's Café often features pies made from fruits grown in their own garden.
6. Coho Café & Bakery
Coho Café & Bakery is a cozy spot in Tofte, known for its baked goods and pies. This café is a great place to relax and enjoy a slice.
- Location: Tofte
- Must-Try: Mixed Berry Pie
- Fun Fact: Coho Café & Bakery is part of the Bluefin Bay Family of Resorts, offering stunning lake views with your pie.
Hidden Gems Await
Minnesota's North Shore offers more than just scenic views. It's home to some of the best pie shops you'll ever find. From the classic apple pie at Betty's Pies to the unique blueberry creations at Rustic Inn Café, each stop offers a slice of heaven. These hidden gems provide not only delicious treats but also a cozy atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. Whether you're a local or just passing through, taking the time to visit these pie shops is a must. They add a sweet touch to any trip, making your journey along the North Shore even more memorable. So next time you're in the area, don't miss out on these delightful spots. Your taste buds will thank you.
Related travel guides: Your Perfect Minnesota North Shore Road Trip, 15 Hidden Towns on Minnesota's North Shore, and Hidden Agate Beaches Of Minnesota's North Shore.
